Is Madden 2010 THAT much better than Gameloft's NFL '10

[wonderva]

I currently have Gameloft's game [99 cents woot], but I was thinking of getting Madden if only it was extremely better than NFL 2010 to warrant 6.99$.

So is it, and in what ways?

[Andgut]

Its alot better but not worth the money
If you want another football game get backbreaker

[S.I.D. CrAzY]

I personally thought they both sucked. Couldn't enjoy either of them. I've been more in Super Shock Football than these two.

Backbreaker is good too.

[backtothis]

IMHO I think gamelofts game is better. Big Albie did a comparison between the two a while back. Go search that up in the the reviews. He always knows how to put it best heh.

[Jack111]

you forgot the they both suck option in the poll

[kiddblue]

I bought the Gameloft version and am balking at paying the Madden price right now. I think the Gameloft version is simple but can be frustrating the way they use their buttons.

I am checking out the Backbreaker and Super Shock football.

PS Here's the comparison thread - http://forums.toucharcade.com/showthread.php?t=25388

And another review of Madden for you - http://forums.toucharcade.com/showthread.php?t=24948&highlight=gameloft+madden

[GodSon]

Boom! :D

[swishinj]

I personally thought they both sucked. Couldn't enjoy either of them. I've been more in Super Shock Football than these two.

Backbreaker is good too.

Gotta aggre but super shock SUCKS!!!!!!!!!

[S.I.D. CrAzY]

Gotta aggre but super shock SUCKS!!!!!!!!!

I like it for what it is, not really a good title if you're looking for a football simulator.

But the game never set out to be that, for what it's supposed to be it's damn near perfect.

[kingkong120]

As much as I like the Madden series, I don't think it's that the iphone version is that much better than Gameloft's version. Other than being able to draw your own plays, I really don't see that much of an improvement over NFL 2010.

It's amazing on the PS3 though.

[PacSun4dc]

if your a football fan (me) I would pick Madden 10 because that is made by EA sports the real franchise..to me $7 is worth it :)

[Will090]

I personally thought they both sucked. Couldn't enjoy either of them. I've been more in Super Shock Football than these two.

Backbreaker is good too.

Amen

[wonderva]

Backbreaker isn't a football simulator like NFL or Madden though.

However, is NBA Live 2010, as a game, more fun than Madden?

[Will090]

Backbreaker isn't a football simulator like NFL or Madden though.

However, is NBA Live 2010, as a game, more fun than Madden?

Yes, relatively. NBA Live is bad while Madden Sucks

[freedog]

Madden is better but the difference and amount that its better is not enough to boast about. Its just slightly better.

I still seek a better NFL iphone experience if that tells you anything.