We would like feedback from the TA community on what you guys think is the best icon for our soon to be released game: RABID GOPHERS <---- Click for preview thread.
2 is the best design wise 8 looks good the rest are missing something that gives them impact and makes them pop.
2 and 3. Voted 2. The images in 7 and 8 are too small, the detail is lost. 4 and 5 will annoy people who don't like randomly shaped icons.
Thanks everyone for the quick response and feedback! Ironically, our 2 favs internally are 2 and 6 as well. The second one has that "creepy peering through a window" feel, and something about #6 is very striking (which is what we were going for). It's interesting to see #7 making a push... The poll will continued to be up, so if you haven't voted yet, then go for it!
Any more votes coming in? Looking like we will have to decide between #2 and #6 (which is, ironically, where we were before we even did the poll) Also, we will be taking a different poll in a day or so, so watch for that. This one could involve GIVEAWAYS! More details when we submit the poll...