It's a really close match, and if you're an average gamer, they'll look all the same to you. Right now my brother is yelling about how awesome Luxor is, and I must agree with him. Don't know why, it's just the feeling I guess.
Mine would be more like this. Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Luxor > Stoneloops > Atlantic
Atlantis>Luxor>Stoneloops Atlantis and Luxor are the only contenders really, but I give Atlantis the edge due to the fact it has the "puzzles" to break... when I play Luxor it feels almost as though I have nothing to do, whereas ASP you're tacking the moving balls but also trying to free up some time to destroy the puzzles and stop the waves coming, the whole multitasking thing really gives it a chaotic edge. Plus I just don't dig the Luxor graphics, they're a bit outdated.
agreed, I don't think I'll buy any of the others either. I like stoneloops but I have no need for another game of the genre .
I think the Luxor fans are repping it just for the sake of being Luxor A bit like how people claim Super Mario Bros to be the best Mario game, when there's really no reason not to regard Super Mario World as the superior game.
I agree. I think Atlantis has the more polished graphics. I also like the added challenge Atlantis brings to the genre.
Someone should tally the votes (how many 1st place for Luxor, 1st for Atlantis, 2nd for Atlantis, 3rd for Stoneloops etc) and combine them on the first post
Haven't played Luxor or Atlantis yet. Stoneloops was fantastic and from the looks of it Atlantis does look better both grafix and gameplay wise. Too bad I missed it at 99cents. But Luxor doesn't look any better than stoneloops. I really doubt I'll be getting it at all. Atlantis, as soon as it's 99cents again. Luxor, don't really think so.
I only have stoneloops. From the screens, i would go for atlantis. It looks much better than luxor. The graphics on luxor really looks bad and i believe looks is important for this type of game.