Hey! I'm finalizing work on my new project - Punch a Hole, but I'm having really hard time deciding which icon to use. I've came up with three simple ideas: I'd love to go with the first idea, since it represent a tile that awaits to be punched, but I'm afraid it's too general. The second and third ones contain a ball which represents Punch a Hole a bit better but on the other hand I feel it clutters the icons. I could use some feedback, feel free to speak up! Here's how the game looks:
I definitely like to middle one most. The first one is so empty it might raise some curiosity but personally I'd go with the middle one.
I have to say that from a players perspective I'd find it hard to distinguish anything about the game from any of these icons. Maybe a little hint at some game action or a title might shed some light on what you're offering with the app.
I vote for the middle icon Your icon is good because it's simple comparing to the other millions icons, no need to make a better one. .
All are too simple for my taste. I feel like I could've made them! I'd suggest 'zooming out' on the icon a bit, so you see pieces of the neighboring tiles. Or at the bare minimum choosing the blue dot to highlight.
I actually like the simplicity of 'em. It's different. However, when I look at any of 'em, first thing I think of is golf game.
You're right! After finger swipe the cue appears and strikes the ball. The intention was to keeps things familiar - everyone knows how billiard balls collide with each other and how they fall into pockets.
