I err on the side of positivity because I'd rather encourage devs to become better than chase them away.
I respect a "tell it like it is" attitude. I'm pretty blunt by default. Nevertheless, there's a big difference between playing a game and panning it, and being insulting without actually having played it. Doesn't seem particularly fair.
I'll give this a shot--Sanuku seems excited, at any rate. But it's kind of a bummer it came out on the same night as Joe Danger. I'm afraid it'll suffer in comparison.