Originally Posted by chimpman252
I'm not specifically looking for a shooter, just something that has a similar engrossing feel
Walking Dead: The Game. Doesn't get any more engrossing than that. Bastion is also very atmospheric, but best played on iPad due to larger screen and retina visuals. KOTOR is also a great RPG, but also very dated and iPad exclusive. Deus Ex is decent but inferior experience compared to Human Revolution.