TA Forums Game of the Week! (Dec 13th)

[ninjackid]

Mutant Fridge Mayhem gets my vote!

[syntheticvoid]

Maybe we could have a separate iPad only vote... But make it bi-weekly or even just monthly, since there's not many iPad only titles every month....

Just a suggestion...

[Echoseven]

Originally Posted by syntheticvoid

Maybe we could have a separate iPad only vote... But make it bi-weekly or even just monthly, since there's not many iPad only titles every month....

Just a suggestion...

Too complicated for normal release polls, I think. Guess I could try a monthly iPad only poll, but it's pretty obvious which games would win since the releases are that rare.

I mean... How many iPad-only games released this year could you name that you'd nominate/vote for? I don't think there would be 12. Unfair as it may sometimes be, there's just not enough to justify separate polls.

[syntheticvoid]

Originally Posted by Echoseven

Too complicated for normal release polls, I think. Guess I could try a monthly iPad only poll, but it's pretty obvious which games would win since the releases are that rare.

I mean... How many iPad-only games released this year could you name that you'd nominate/vote for? I don't think there would be 12. Unfair as it may sometimes be, there's just not enough to justify separate polls.

Right on. Thanks for considering it anyway. =o)

[Echoseven]

Now that I've joined the iPadians, I'd love there to be more iPad exclusive games. Guess there just aren't enough of us though.

Speaking of which, I'm excited about Tiny Thief!

[awp69]

Originally Posted by Echoseven

Too complicated for normal release polls, I think. Guess I could try a monthly iPad only poll, but it's pretty obvious which games would win since the releases are that rare.

I mean... How many iPad-only games released this year could you name that you'd nominate/vote for? I don't think there would be 12. Unfair as it may sometimes be, there's just not enough to justify separate polls.

Had one more thought that might be a decent compromise. What if an iPad only game didn't get enough nominations when it was released to be included in the poll still be eligible when they get re-releases or go Universal? There's probably only a handful of iPad games that crossover to the iPhone.

For instance, from what I can tell Autumn Dynasty didn't get enough nominations when it came out in May to make the GoTW poll. But if it was eligible, maybe it would have this week.

Nothing's perfect and certainly don't want to create more work for you Echo. Just another thought. Then I'll drop it...I promise .

[Echoseven]

That's an interesting thought.

Would mean I have to dig up the GOTW poll from around when the game was originally released...
And have to be careful of games like Bastion which, despite being iPad only, were still nominated and even won, if I remember correctly.


The thing is, the truly outstanding iPad games don't have problems with the current poll set-up (Bastion, Aquaria and Machinarium, to name a few). Knowing that, do you think it would be fair to let the more niche games get a second chance?

[Exact-Psience]

Originally Posted by Echoseven

iPadians

Heresy! I am an ipadist!

[Connector]

Originally Posted by Exact-Psience

Heresy! I am an ipadist!

Me too, I'm here!!! This week playing my ipad as a console via hdmi and airplay, using wireless headphones now, and playing Alpha Zero with two styluses! How much more of an ipad fanatic can you get???

[awp69]

Originally Posted by Echoseven

That's an interesting thought.

Would mean I have to dig up the GOTW poll from around when the game was originally released...
And have to be careful of games like Bastion which, despite being iPad only, were still nominated and even won, if I remember correctly.


The thing is, the truly outstanding iPad games don't have problems with the current poll set-up (Bastion, Aquaria and Machinarium, to name a few). Knowing that, do you think it would be fair to let the more niche games get a second chance?

I don't know. Guess it's probably best to just leave it as is. Just know that, as you can tell, the number of people who still suffer on our little iPhones and iPod Touches probably still greatly outnumber the iPadists.

But when the iPad people do come out in force, like your example of Bastion, they can still conquer us. So guess it's best to just let it be. Even though I definitely would have nominated Autumn Dynasty this week, you're right in that it is more of a niche game that would have not won anyway.

I'm trying to think. Did Incoboto win as an iPad game before it came to the iPhone/Touch? That may have been one that could have won when it "crossed over".

Anyway, just rambling on....so there's likely not a really good solution to the issue....if there really even is an issue.