Originally Posted by TheGreatWhiteApe
Second one is the best mainly because he is looking at you and looks happy. Mayne take some detail out of the seaweed at the bottom, and try getting some more contrast between the character and the background to make him pop out a bit. Looks pretty good. Always hard designing a good character that works in a circle shape.
Thanks for the feedback. maybe I'll get better as an artist but for now I only use really basic shapes like circles, squares. I don't even consider myself as an artist but I'm pretty happy with the result for my first game.