★ TouchArcade needs your help. Click here to support us on Patreon.

iPhone: Accelerometer steering, done right and done wrong

09-17-2008, 03:13 AM
#1
Joined: Sep 2008
Location: Berlin/Germany
Posts: 946
Accelerometer steering, done right and done wrong

Hello,

right now we have quite a few racers and I'm a bit disappointed how they use the accelerometer. What do you think?

Pole Position and Moto Chaser: Perfectly done. Your car/motocycle reacts immediately even to the smallest tilting of your phone.

Nitro Kart 3D: Well done as well, but the don't keep the horizon flat. So while tilting the whole game graphics "tilt away".

Cro Mag Rally: Well done like the first three, but you feel like riding a tank on ice and you can drive on walls, which at least is strange.

Asphalt 4: Too sensitive, prefers drifting every time, activates the nitro whenever it wants. Overall this could be a nice control scheme, but you have to concentrate more on how and when to tilt instead of playing the game.

GTS World Racing: They broke it completely. This could have been THE reference for a racer, because you not only steer but also accelerate and brake with tilting the phone. Here's how the broke it: When you tilt your phone just a little bit, every other racer reacts, but GTS does just nothing. Now you tilt even more, and THEN the game reacts. It puts you on a pre-calculated vector curve and then drives on it like on rails. That how it feels: Driving on rails. You never have the feeling to directly control the game, but instead you yell at somebody miles away and he does the steering - after a while. It gets a bit better when using the formula 1 car and setting the steering to 100%, but you never the the "real" feeling of the other racers.


So, overall, I currently have Moto Chaser, Pole Position and Asphalt on my iPhone. Moto Chaser makes the most fun, Pole Position has a really really great retro feeling to it and is the ideal racer for a few minutes and Asphalt 4 is the only one which feels like a "real game", but you just have to concentrate too much on the controls to have fun with it, especially when playing it on the bus, where nitro activates *everytime*.

What's your opinion on that? Which game do you like more, regarding the use of the accelerometer?

Last edited by Oliver; 09-17-2008 at 08:42 AM.
09-17-2008, 07:51 AM
#2
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 4,481
I only have Cro-Mag and don't like the controls, plus the game is just boring. It's made me hesitant to buy any others, at least not for $10 and without a demo. If they'd just release free demos I think they'd gain quite a few sales. That they don't makes me think that the controls must stink, just like Cro-Mag, or worse.