★ TouchArcade needs your help. Click here to support us on Patreon.

TA 2010 Buyer Guide... disappointing?

12-25-2010, 08:34 AM
#1
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,609
TA 2010 Buyer Guide... disappointing?

Am I alone to feel this 2010 buyer guide very disappointing?

The choice of a buyer guide instead of the standards (boring) goty lists is quite smart because it offers much more freedom. That's a good point but I felt this freedom hasn't been exploited deeply enough and feel it ends with something mildly deep and mildly superficial and amateurish.

The first very unpleasant feeling is that some some games are put in some categories they don't relate at all. This is a terrible clue that this guide has been made in haste and without the care and polishing it deserves to last more than few days. The worst example is certainly Monkey Island 2 in the Sim/Strategy section. But there are other like Cut The Rope, Tilt to Live, Fastar! (not a single platform in the game!), Lego Harry Potter (Nope Spell and Fantasy don't mean RPG).

The second very unpleasant feeling is coming from the categories themselves. Most are unimaginative, just fitting the very common standards, some weird merges like make one category with Simulation and Strategy, an almost complete ignorance of gaming specifics on iPhone/iPad. A buying guide with no categories like Tower Defense, Hidden Object Adventures, Dual Stick shooters, Brick Breaker, Match 3 variations, and more is not a choice from a site that pretend have a deep knowledge on indie gaming and idevice gaming.

I mean I would expect from a TA 2010 buying a much more deep dip into 2010 gaming on iDevice. As it is it's more a pointless stuff and I haven't discover a single game in it, which is quite weird when you think I started played games on iPad only at end of June.

I have other grip against this guide but those above are the main points and the other points are harder to debate because a precise selection list can always be questionable, it's a difficult art. I'll just mention some obvious points.

Firstly a quote, at first I think TA made the choice to reject from the lists any game flawed with some technical problems, even when the effect on gameplay was minor until I noticed Alaron, The Incident, Robot Unicorn Attack... I don't reproach this, I just quote it and I'm fine with that, I'll never ever stop arguing that technicals aren't the point of a game, only the overall end result matter, at least for non superficial gamers.

So on this base only few quotes:
  • 2010 Puzzle without: Beyond Ynth, Let's Create Pottery, Master of Alchemy, Puzzle Quest 2, Call of Atlantis, Shadow Runner.
  • 2010 Platformer without: Despicable Me Minion Mania, Trundle, Somersault, Don't Let Go: A Platformer, Frogatto, Prince of Persia Warrior Within, Stick Golf, Ice Cube Adventures.
  • 2010 RPG without: Puzzle Quest 2 and Rimelands, lol.
  • 2010 Board section is just ridiculous even me with not an in deep knowledge of this type of game can quote it. I won't lost time to quote a selection, players with a deeper knowledge of those type of game can do it.
  • The strategy section
  • 2010 Retro without: R Type, Frogatto, and more.
And I could add ton more. The problem is when you pretend do a 2010 buyer guide, you can't have the superficial approach of standards GOTY.
12-25-2010, 09:05 AM
#2
Joined: Sep 2009
Location: USA
Posts: 1,359
What?

I think the selection and categories are fine, for the most part. If they had listed FIFA 11, Galaxy on Fire 2, and Modern Combat 2 instead of X2 Soccer, Warpgate, and Archtype, it could have been better.

12-25-2010, 09:44 AM
#3
Joined: Aug 2009
Location: Hungary
Posts: 3,949
It's subjective, don't complain.
12-25-2010, 09:49 AM
#4
Joined: Apr 2009
Location: USA
Posts: 2,437
Quote:
Originally Posted by Balu` View Post
It's subjective, don't complain.
exactly.....i happen to love nhl 2k11.....but so many people hate it.

i love it for the fact that its hockey on my ipod

same with other games.....they couldnt please everyone

ssɐ sıɥ dn ɯǝɥʇ ǝʌoɥs puɐ sƃuıɹ dıɥsuoıdɯɐɥɔ sǝıɹǝs plɹoʍ ㄥᄅ sǝǝʞuɐʎ ǝɥʇ ǝʞɐʇ uɐɔ ıpɹɐɹıƃ ǝoɾ
12-25-2010, 10:14 AM
#5
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 742
I agree with Qordobo's opinion. The TA list is confusing, messy and very incomplete while also being too long. It shows a lack of discipline. Yeah, that's my opinion. You're welcome to voice yours too, cuz that's what discussion forums are for.
12-25-2010, 10:46 AM
#6
Joined: Feb 1983
Location: Barcelona
Posts: 1,268,711
We spent close to a week on the iPhone and iPad lists and I skipped a family function on the 23rd to make sure it was complete for everyone on Christmas Eve. Thanks for the vote of confidence, all of these comments on both the forums and the front page are truly heartwarming.
12-25-2010, 10:55 AM
#7
Joined: Mar 2009
Location: Rio Rancho NEW MEXICO Yes, its a state >:l
Posts: 2,895
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hodapp View Post
We spent close to a week on the iPhone and iPad lists and I skipped a family function on the 23rd to make sure it was complete for everyone on Christmas Eve. Thanks for the vote of confidence, all of these comments on both the forums and the front page are truly heartwarming.
Well I liked the buyers guide except there was no super quick hook, but that was my only complaint. I thought the guide was complete, and simple to understand. The list also did a good job of incorporating games from earlier in the years, like Fruit Ninja. You must remember, you can never please everyone, especially in a forum full of people who hold very strong opinions on certain games.

Happy Holidays btw.

Plus+, Openfeint, and Gameloft Live Username: Vester
Add me on GameCenter: Sock Merchant
2/6/11 the Green Bay Packers win Super Bowl XLV
12-25-2010, 10:58 AM
#8
Joined: Jul 2010
Location: Gainesville, FL
Posts: 288
I thought it was great except for the absence of Galaxy on Fire 2. But whenever there are lists like this there will always be those who disagree with the selections. It's amazing how many great games came out this year and I'm glad that they were able to do such a detailed write-up about them. If you're that disappointed then you can contribute to the forum's year in review but I'm pretty sure yours won't be nearly as detailed as the one Hodapp did.

Twitter: @JZWilliams
GameCenter/OpenFeint/GameloftID/Disc Drivin'/Hero Academy: zman2100

Last edited by zman2100; 12-25-2010 at 11:01 AM.
12-25-2010, 11:41 AM
#9
Joined: Apr 2009
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 1,006
You'd think that the phrase "we feel" would have been enough to clearly label it an opinion piece. The article includes a nice mix of apps, popular and niche, and is a fun reflection on 2010. It's got fresh write ups of each featured game - clearly a lot of work went into it. If everyone reading TA agreed on what the best games are, the world would be a boring place

That being said, I agree that some of the category buckets seem a bit forced, and there are a few minor grammatical mistakes (i.e. "will intelligently chooses plays for you"). I think most folk would agree that these are easy to forgive considering the timeliness of the article, and the fact that there's an "Odds and End" category for things which completely_ defied being pigeon holed.
12-25-2010, 11:52 AM
#10
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 996
Quote:
Originally Posted by tsharpfilm View Post
I think the selection and categories are fine, for the most part.
Well, IMHO the absence of point-and-click/text adventure section sticks out like a sore thumb... I really don't understand this choice, as there are a lot of good and even relatively successful games belonging to this category. Then Monkey Island 2 wouldn't have had to be shoehorned where it clearly doesn't belong and other deserving games could have been mentioned, too.

Beyond that, only a couple of mis-categorizations and arguable omissions.

Favorites: Puzzle Quest, The Quest, Sway, Glyder, Reign of Swords, Flight of the Amazon Queen